Comet 3I/ATLAS: The Alien Rumor And What the Experts Say

Comet 3I/ATLAS
BBC Sky At Night Magazine

For a few weeks now, the universe has been teasing us again, dangling another mystery before the eyes of Earth. A bright, fast-moving blur called Comet 3I/ATLAS has become the latest obsession for astronomers, space enthusiasts, and, somehow, even Kim Kardashian.

Discovered on July 1, 2025, by the ATLAS telescope in Chile, 3I/ATLAS isn’t just any comet. It’s allegedly coming from interstellar space, meaning it came from beyond our solar system, drifting through space for what might be millions or even billions of years before deciding to pass through our neighborhood. It’s only the third confirmed interstellar object ever found, following the mysterious ʻOumuamua in 2017 and Borisov in 2019.

When scientists first spotted it, 3I/ATLAS was racing along a path. It swung around the Sun on October 29, 2025, glowing brighter than expected, then something odd happened.

Some people swear it exploded. Others insist it merely flared up, brushing too close to the Sun’s searing heat. Either way, the rumors spread faster than the comet itself.

The Explosion That Might Not Have Been

Social media ran with it first; whispers of an “interstellar explosion,” talk of fragments, wild claims that NASA was hiding something. Videos of “glowing fragments” flooded TikTok, each one more dramatic than the last.

But astronomers quickly stepped in. Observatories around the world reported that 3I/ATLAS was still visible, though dimmer. No debris cloud, no shattered nucleus, no telltale sign of a full breakup. “It hasn’t exploded,” said a Live Science report flatly. “And no, that doesn’t mean it’s an alien spaceship.”

Still, something did happen. As it neared the Sun, 3I/ATLAS brightened rapidly, turned an unusual blue, and developed strange jets, some even pointing toward the Sun instead of away from it. It’s behaviour that’s baffled experts. Normally, comets obey predictable laws of sunlight and ice.

The Alien Talk and What the Experts Say

Then came the inevitable question: could it be alien?

The first person to say it out loud was Harvard astrophysicist Avi Loeb, the same scientist who once proposed that ʻOumuamua might be a probe from another civilization. Loeb claimed that the comet is an alien spacecraft and listed ten “anomalies” about 3I/ATLAS. “When something behaves differently from what we know,” Loeb wrote, “we must be open to all possibilities.”

And that was all the internet needed.

Podcaster Joe Rogan invited Loeb on his show, The Joe Rogan Experience, for a two-hour cosmic chat that bounced between science, philosophy, and pure wonder. “If it’s natural, fine,” Rogan said, half-laughing. “But if it’s not… what the hell do we do with that?”

Meanwhile, Loeb, ever the provocateur, even joked that Kim Kardashian was “welcome to join my research team” after she tweeted: “Wait… what’s the tea on 3I/ATLAS???” NASA quickly replied to calm her 364 million followers: “It’s a comet, not a craft. No aliens. No threat to Earth.”

What Scientists Actually Know

Behind the noise, researchers have been quietly studying 3I/ATLAS in remarkable detail. The James Webb Space Telescope detected that its outer layers are coated in a crust formed by billions of years of cosmic radiation, a kind of protective shell that’s likely been altered since before our Sun even existed. Beneath that, gases rich in carbon dioxide and traces of nickel hint that it came from a cold, distant star system far beyond our reach.

The comet’s tail is stranger still, two of them, actually, stretching in different directions. One trails behind as expected, while the other seems to point toward the Sun, a phenomenon astronomers call an anti-tail. It’s a rare, beautiful sign that this object has been shaped by both solar wind and its own ancient chemistry.

As for the “explosion,” experts say it’s likely a case of extreme outgassing, frozen materials within the comet suddenly vaporizing as sunlight hits, creating a dramatic flash that made it look like a detonation.

No fragments, no alien debris field. Just nature doing what nature does best: surprising us.

Why People Are So Hooked

Part of the fascination with 3I/ATLAS isn’t just science. It’s a story. We’re emotional creatures, drawn to mystery. Every interstellar visitor feels like a message, a postcard from another star system. ʻOumuamua arrived and left us guessing. Borisov reminded us that comets could cross the cosmic ocean. Now 3I/ATLAS has come to remind us that the universe still has surprises hiding between the stars.

Even astronomers admit it’s poetic. “It’s like reading an ancient letter written in stardust,” one NASA researcher said. “Each of these interstellar objects carries a history of another world.”

And while most experts agree this comet is purely natural, they also confess that these encounters stretch the imagination. What if other civilizations are out there, watching their own comet pass through another system and wondering if we might see it?

What Happens Next

3I/ATLAS is still moving fast, almost 60 kilometers per second, and will make its closest approach to Earth around December 19, 2025. However, it’s nothing to be worried about as it will still be about 270 million kilometers away. Scientists will continue to keep an eye on it for months to see whether it truly broke or it is still intact.